Earlham College

Shelly Holt was a two-sport star during her time at Earlham College. She was a three-year letterwinner in both soccer and basketball.
 
In soccer, Holt was a goalkeeper on the North Coast Athletic Conference All-Decade Team (1993-2004), while earning first-team all-conference from 1998-2000. Holt was the NCAC Defensive Player of the Year in 1998. She was also on the NSCAA All-Great Lakes Region 2nd Team in 1998 and 1999. In her time with the Quakers, Holt was the Most Valuable First Year and the Most Valuable Defensive Player from 1998-2000.
 
On the basketball court, she is currently ninth on Earlham's all-time scoring list with 1,057 points. She was a member of the 2000-01 NCAC Tourney runner-up team, while earning all-tournament team honors as a captain for the squad. That same season, Holt was All-NCAC Second Team after being on the All-NCAC Honorable Mention list the previous year.